Ortley Beach is barely one square mile so it's easy to breeze through it coming off the Route 37 bridge over the Barnegat Bay or driving through Lavallette. But for Toms River residents, it's the township's only public beach.
Ortley is separated from the main area of Toms River by the water and from North Dover Beaches/Toms River Township by Lavallette. Unfortunately, instead of just calling the area Ortley Beach, Toms River still sometimes refers to the area as Dover Beaches South. The challenges of being a mapmaker are clear along Barnegat Island.
Give the Jersey Shore
for Father's Day on June 20
Get the scoop on whale watching, minor league baseball, fishing adventures and more with the #1 NJ Travel Guide:100 Things to Do at the Jersey Shore Before You Die. Buy it now and the author will autograph it to your dad.
Along the beach, there's a boardwalk that is interrupted by undeveloped beachfront property. However, there's parking right along most of the Oceanfront road.
Joey Harrison's Surf Club demolished. Boardwalk extension coming?
The building that once housed Joey Harrison’s Surf Club in Ortley Beach was demolished in December 2021 following its purchase by Toms River Township using state Blue Acres funding. Since the demolition, there has been no activity on the site, and it remains fenced off from the public. A parking lot located across the street is also vacant. The township is looking to expand tge Boardwalk near the Surf Club site and add beach access for the public.
Beach Erosion & Lightning Sirens
After several nor'easters this spring, the dunes between Fourth and Eighth Avenues eroded. The township brought in sand to shore up the area, but there's still a steeper slope in this part of the beach. However, most of the beach is easily accessed so come and enjoy.
Like the Brick beaches to the north, Toms Rivers Township plans to install a new lightning warning system by the end of June. Sirens at the Lord House on the north and the Block House on the south will warn beachgoers to leave. Township officials are acting in response to the death last year of a lifeguard in Berkeley Township due to lightning strike.
Barnacle Bill's mini-golf is one of the Shore's best
For 55 years, a 25-foot bearded “giant” has towered over the ninth hole at Barnacle Bill’s Amusements in Ortley Beach. He was packed away as Superstorm Sandy hit. The course was badly damaged during storm. What had been an old-fashioned course was transformed in 2013 by Harris Miniature Golf, the industry leader in mini-golf courses. The course is now more challenging and interesting with Bill squarely in the middle of the action.
Barnegat Bay is so long and wide that fishermen and boaters were always looking for a quick way in from and out to the ocean along the thin Barnegat Island. Inlets came and went with major storms. One such inlet was the Cranberry Inlet which is roughly where Ortley Beach meets Seaside Heights.
An entertaining passage from Old Times in Old Monmouth details that the Cranberry Inlet probably "broke through about 1750." It served as an important place during the American Revolution as rebels hid there after attacking British vessels headed to New York. The inlet "closed about the year 1812," and efforts were made by local landowner Michael Ortley to re-open it. The writer explains:
"He worked at it off and on for several years and spent considerable money in the undertaking. At length one day a large company of men volunteered to aid him in completing the enterprise. In the evening after finishing it, Mr. Ortley and his friends had quite a merry time in celebrating the completion of the work. But great was their disappointment the following morning to find that the running of the tide, which they had supposed would work the inlet deeper, had, on the contrary, raised a bulkhead of sand sufficiently large to close it up, and the result was the inlet was closed much more expeditiously than it was opened."
Ortley nevertheless triumphed in a different way
While Michael Ortley never did reopen the Cranberry Inlet, his family name carries on. Michael W. Ortley was a developer in the area. A tract purchased from him eventually became the Borough of Lavallette immediately to the north. (Ironically, Ortley Avenue sits in Lavallette, not Ortley Beach.)
For many years, there was an Ortley Inn, opened by Arthur Lord where the present Lord House Lifeguard Station stands. The Inn burned down in 1922. Lord built a single family home at the beach where it remained until after a major storm in 1962. The family's long association with the area is noted in the naming of the Lifeguard Station.
Tips for Visiting Ortley Beach
What's New: Beach badges stay the same for 2022.
Access and Parking: The only way to access Ortley Beach is along busy Route 35 from Lavallette to the north or from Seaside Heights to the south. Route 35 is divided into a north and south section, separated by an "island" of homes and businesses in the middle. Street parking is free including the municipal lot at 3rd Avenue and the beach.
Amenities: There are restrooms and outdoor showers.
Beaches: There are two walkways that are interrupted by several large buildings along the beachfront so a person has to walk up and down several times. Beach badges are required for access to all beaches. Full season badges are $60; weekly badges are $35. For people 62 years old or over, a lifetime beach badge is only $15. Daily badges are $10 Monday through Friday and $11 on weekends and holidays starting June 18. No cost for people under the age of 12. Beach buggies are permitted October 1 through May 14 with a $25 permit issued through the township.
Follow Jersey Shore author and expert R.C. Staab as he recounts his 2021 walk of every beach along the 139 miles of the Jersey Shore coastline from Sandy Hook to Cape May. Read all updated stories at www.JerseyShoreWalk.com.